Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion

    E-scrap feedstock competition mixed amid investments

    Open pit copper mine in Arizona.

    Trump touts aggressive US critical mineral goals

    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion

    E-scrap feedstock competition mixed amid investments

    Open pit copper mine in Arizona.

    Trump touts aggressive US critical mineral goals

    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
No Result
View All Result
Home Plastics

Inside the Circle: The bottle bill’s unfinished business

Bill ShiremanbyBill Shireman
October 13, 2026
in Plastics, Recycling
Study explores  reusable containers in California DRS

Rokas Tenys / Shutterstock

California’s bottle bill turned 40 on September 29. I’m proud of the role I played in making it happen, bringing together the unlikely coalition that made it possible.

Already a veteran of roughly ten years of losses to an industry alliance that had mastered the science of defeating deposit laws, I was pretty sure the traditional approach of waging an even bigger war against industry wouldn’t work for us. So before we launched a new campaign in 1986, I did something unusual.

I spoke with our opponents. Sat down with them in any office I could get myself into. And asked a pretty simple question: How can we make you want to beat us less?

When I showed up at Bill Coors’ office in Golden, Colorado, he led me to a back room, opened a file drawer, and pulled out a folder marked “Closed Loop System.” It was a model for a bottle bill that would cost much less than the traditional approach by replacing some command-and-control mandates with market-based mechanisms. The most significant would spare retailers from having to take back every container directly. Instead, a network of independent recycling centers could emerge to provide that service.

Chuck Collings, the president of Raley’s Supermarkets, turned out to be my next hero. A conservative, he was precisely the kind of executive my allies would think least likely to help us. But when I spoke with him, he told me he was ashamed of his own side. He thought they had been untruthful in their last campaigns against us. Retailers were eager to avoid another public battle. They valued their reputations. Being opposed to a sensible environmental law was not something they looked forward to. He told me: “If you solve my problem, I’ll solve yours. I’ll get the rest of the grocers aboard.”

He kept his promise. The brewers joined the retailers, and soon the soft-drink bottlers and the unions that served them all.

We had a deal. Republican and Democratic lawmakers voted for the measure, authored by Democratic Assemblyman Burt Margolin. Republican Governor George Deukmejian signed it into law.

Since then, Californians have recycled more than half a trillion bottles and cans—nearly 550 billion, according to CalRecycle. All that astonishes me. I’m grateful beyond measure.

Three things made the deal possible. We asked before we designed. We found the one cost our opponents most wanted to avoid, managing the logistics of redemption, and we removed it. And we learned who could bring the rest along. It was the grocers, not the bottlers.

The law worked because the water flowed downhill. The incentives made sense for everyone.

California needs that method again. Environmental organizations have challenged the regulations implementing SB 54, the state’s packaging law, arguing they weaken it. Industry groups are pursuing delay, amendment, repeal or litigation. The state’s producer responsibility organization, Circular Action Alliance (CAA), sends its final plan to CalRecycle this month.

SB 54 also asks for what we never delivered in 1986, and that I am still eager to accomplish. When I first set out to pass the bottle bill, refillable containers still had a substantial presence in the marketplace. By the time we passed it, they had largely disappeared. The beverage industry consolidated around linear systems that reward scale: produce centrally, ship long distances, sell, discard. So we have a system that recycles, but does not refill.

By January 1, 2027, CAA must cut the plastic packaging and food serviceware its members sell in California by 10 percent. At least a fifth of that cut has to come from shifting to reusable or refillable packaging.

This matters beyond packaging. Many circular activities reward proximity: repair, maintain, refill, restore, resell, collect, compost and remanufacture. They are the key to a future economy that complements global institutions with abundant local enterprises. We can be global where scale creates value and local where proximity creates value.

Nobody has yet found the design that makes source reduction pay, yet source reduction is where we get the biggest environmental benefits. I don’t have the answer. In 1986, I didn’t either, until I asked. So here are the two questions I would ask now.

To producers: What is the one cost you most want to avoid? Under SB 54 you pay fees on the packaging you sell, and the law’s fee system is intended to recognize source-reduction performance. Could those fees be built around the cost you fear most, so that every pound of material you eliminate reduces your future compliance cost? This is the test: a packaging engineer should be able to walk into the CFO’s office and say, give me the money to redesign this product.

To retailers: Would you play the role the grocers played in 1986? They brought the brewers along. Today you can use supplier scorecards, purchasing commitments, shelf preference and shared standards to make lower-material designs commercially valuable. That matters most for refill, because a new system needs early volume before its infrastructure becomes economical.

Forty years ago, we made progress by asking our opponents what would make it easier for them to do what was right. Nobody has yet asked that question about source reduction under SB 54.

It is time once again for the parties at each other’s throats—battling to reduce SB 54’s costs or raise its environmental benefits—to sit down at a table and work out how to do both.

We’ve done it before.

We can do it again.

Let’s start now.

Tags: Beverage ContainersCaliforniaContainer DepositsEPRRepair & Reuse
TweetShare
Bill Shireman

Bill Shireman

Bill Shireman is a longtime environmental entrepreneur and policy innovator. He helped write California’s original bottle recycling law, which has helped recover hundreds of billions of containers. As CEO of Solution Citizen, he works at the intersection of circular economy policy, democratic renewal, and cultural transformation—and occasionally wanders rainforests looking for better ideas than the ones we currently have. He recently launched Circle America, a new affinity group and campaign for advancing a circular economy and culture. Learn more and join the community at CircleAmerica.us

Related Stories

The AI tsunami

The AI tsunami

byJim Puckett
November 19, 2026

AI data centers and the devices they make obsolete could generate 8.6 to 13.1 million metric tons of e-waste a...

Thrift’s seat at the textile EPR table

byStefanie Valentic
November 19, 2026

Under California’s textile EPR law, every Goodwill in the state counts as a producer, even when new goods are under...

A call to action: End markets and EPR

Recycling policy moves toward implementation

byAntoinette Smith
November 19, 2026

US EPR programs for packaging are starting up amid legal and operational uncertainty, said APR's Kate Bailey during a recent...

California expansion gives Solar Panel Recycling national reach

California expansion gives Solar Panel Recycling national reach

byPaul Lane
November 16, 2026

The company continues to build its capacity in anticipation of a coming surge of panel decommissioning.

Teen takes e-scrap education beyond the classroom

Teen takes e-scrap education beyond the classroom

byKeith Loria
November 13, 2026

Minjun Gim uses device teardowns to explain recovery while exploring how access and repair can keep electronics out of the...

Vessel gives excess inventory a second life

Vessel gives excess inventory a second life

byPaul Lane
November 13, 2026

The recently rebranded company helps manufacturers redistribute product more cheaply than destroying it.

Load More
Next Post
Removing an eBike battery pack.

EPR’s next fight is over embedded batteries

2026 Buyers’ Guide

Equipment, services and technology suppliers serving the recycling industry.

Browse the Guide

More Posts

Closeup of PP with a chasing arrows recycling symbol.

PureCycle, WM sign rare 3-year bales contract

November 16, 2026

Goodwill eyes EPR revenue, starting with waste audit

November 12, 2026

Alphabet’s Materra wants recyclers to see molecules, not bottles

November 13, 2026
Adam Gendell

PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

November 16, 2026
Solarcycle, Korea Zinc merge in critical mineral venture

Solarcycle, Korea Zinc merge in critical mineral venture

November 18, 2026

E-scrap feedstock competition mixed amid investments

November 19, 2026
RecyClass hits 500 EU recyclability evals

EU PET import codes set to begin

November 18, 2026
The missing link in e-plastic recycling

The missing link in e-plastic recycling

October 28, 2026
NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

November 4, 2026
Open pit copper mine in Arizona.

Trump touts aggressive US critical mineral goals

November 19, 2026
Load More

About & Publications

About Us

Staff
Job Listings

Archive

Magazines

Work With Us

Advertise
Contact
Terms and Privacy

Newsletters

Get the latest recycling news and analysis delivered to your inbox every week. Stay ahead on industry trends, policy updates, and insights from programs, processors, and innovators.

Subscribe

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
  • Recycling
  • E-Scrap
  • Plastics
  • Policy Now
  • Conferences
    • E-Scrap Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Magazines – Old
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Archive
  • Job Listings
  • Staff
Subscribe
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.