Pandemic-prompted lockdowns have crippled tax revenues nationwide, sending municipal leaders scrambling to patch gaping budget holes. In many cases, recycling programs have been affected.
As recently reported by Smart Cities Dive, a survey by the U.S. Conference of Mayors and the National League of Cities revealed that almost every single city leader polled indicated they’re now facing budget shortfalls.
Resource Recycling took a closer look at how three cities are addressing recycling as they make cuts: New York City and Santa Monica, Calif., both proposing cuts to recycling programs, and Philadelphia, which wants to protect recycling service alongside police and fire protection.
A bite out of recycling in the Big Apple
Facing a steep drop in revenues, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio has offered a budget for next year that slashes funding for organics composting, scrap electronics recycling, household hazardous waste collection, and recycling outreach programs.
The executive budget makes the following cuts to New York Department of Sanitation (DSNY) recycling-related programs, organized from most money saved to least:
- Temporary suspension of organics program and organics processing: $21 million expense reduction.
- Temporary suspension of community composting subsidy: $3.5 million.
- Suspension of e-scrap curbside collection: $3.4 million.
- Reduction in funding for recycling outreach programs: $2.9 million.
- Temporary suspension of solvents, automotive, flammables, and electronics (SAFE) collection events and special waste sites: $2.2 million.
The budget, which covers fiscal year 2021 (July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2021), reduces expenses by $3.4 billion, or 3.7%, compared with the fiscal year 2020 budget.
City cuts extend ‘zero waste’ timeline
On the West Coast, a city that has aggressively pushed for zero waste – and notched some sky-high recycling rates in the process – is considering deep cuts to its programs.
The Los Angeles-area city of Santa Monica, Calif. is looking at cuts in its Office of Sustainability and the Environment, including eliminating zero waste policy and program development, support for compliance with bans on single-use plastic bags and takeout food containers, and more.
Featured as a Community Spotlight in Resource Recycling in 2017, Santa Monica has achieved diversion rates well over twice the national average. It has a goal of achieving 95% diversion by 2030.
But now, with the pandemic-prompted lockdowns stifling tax revenues, the city of 92,000 people is facing a $72 million shortfall in its budget through June 30; then, during the next fiscal year starting July 1, the city is anticipating a $154 million shortfall.
Amid public angst over his proposed budget cuts, Santa Monica’s city manager resigned last month, according to The Los Angeles Times.
The Santa Monica City Council is scheduled on May 5 to consider a plan to dip into reserve funds, consolidate departments and lay off staff. Among the many impacts, the plan will mean significantly extending the timeline to achieve zero waste, water self-sufficiency and carbon neutrality, according to the city.
“The Office of Sustainability and the Environment will be smaller in size but will remain dedicated to setting current and past work on a course consistent with our value of building a sustainable future and a clean and healthy environment for the generations to come,” according to a summary of the plan.
City of Brotherly Love shows recycling some love
The city of Philadelphia is looking to implement steep budget cuts, but the administration is prioritizing recycling as an essential service.
In his revised fiscal year 2021 budget and five-year plan proposal, Mayor Jim Kenney is proposing to protect recycling service alongside police, fire and emergency medical services, libraries, recreation centers, education and others. In a statement, Kenney said garbage and single-stream recycling collection will continue, with some adjustments.
In early March, Kenney presented a fiscal year 2021 budget proposal to the Philadelphia City Council. Then, the pandemic crippled the economy, resulting in a $650 million projected shortfall in that proposed budget. Kenney’s administration presented a revised document on May 1.
“We are trimming city services down to the most essential, imposing layoffs on hundreds of workers, and reducing or eliminating some programs that are simply no longer affordable,” Kenney stated. “This is not what I want for our residents – but such drastic actions are necessary as we contend with both a pandemic and an economic catastrophe.”
Also the subject of a past Community Spotlight in Resource Recycling, Philadelphia has a goal of sending nothing to disposal by 2035. City crews collect material from about 540,000 households. They collect about 12,000 tons of recyclables monthly from homes.
More stories about local programs
- Largest commingled MRF in North America adds robots
- MRFs move ahead with multi-million-dollar upgrades
- How Phoenix fits into Balcones’ growth plans