Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion
    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    A five star ranking with one under a microscope

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 9

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion
    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    A five star ranking with one under a microscope

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 9

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
No Result
View All Result
Home E-Scrap

Major OEM settles in Closed Loop cleanup case

byJared Paben
November 19, 2020
in E-Scrap
Major OEM settles in Closed Loop cleanup case

Sony Electronics agreed to pay $1.2 million to settle allegations that the company is liable for CRT materials abandoned by Closed Loop Refining and Recovery.

The San Diego-based OEM reached a legal agreement with Garrison Southfield Park and Olymbec USA, landlords that leased warehouses in Columbus, Ohio to Closed Loop.

Closed Loop failed in 2016, leaving an estimated 128 million pounds at Garrison Southfield Park’s two adjacent facilities and about 30 million pounds at Olymbec USA’s warehouse. Cleanup is underway.

In August 2020, the landlords sued nine electronics manufacturers – ASUS Computer International, Dell Technologies, Haier America, LG Electronics USA, Micro Center, Premio, Samsung Electronics America, Sony Electronics, Westinghouse Digital – and one stewardship group: Electronic Manufacturers Recycling Management Co. (MRM), which fulfills legally mandated collection and recycling programs in 20 states on behalf of manufacturers.

Sony is the first OEM to settle and agree to help fund the CRT cleanup. Two OEMs, Dell and Micro Center, have filed defenses and counterclaims against the landlords, and other manufacturers haven’t yet responded in court.

When they were named in the lawsuit, the OEMs joined a long list of existing defendants in the federal district court case. In March 2019, Garrison Southfield Park and Olymbec USA filed a lawsuit against dozens of e-scrap companies that shipped CRTs to Closed Loop in Ohio.

Since then, 25 e-scrap defendants have reached settlements totaling over $3.1 million. Eleven other e-scrap companies continue to defend themselves in court, with some leveling their own claims against the landlords. Another seven companies have gone out of business or failed to appear in court.

Sony reaches agreement

Sony’s settlement was submitted to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio on Nov. 11. Sony’s vice president of North America Customer Service, Timothy McGowan, who oversees e-scrap recycling programs, signed it on Sept. 25.

If approved by the judge, the agreement obligates Sony to pay $1.2 million to fund removal and remediation of about 5.5% of the approximately 160 million pounds at the facilities. The judge overseeing the case hasn’t rejected any of the previous settlements.

To date, the e-scrap companies’ settlement amounts have been calculated based on the amount of material they shipped to Closed Loop (although not all settling defendants have been obligated to pay for 100% of what they shipped). Most of the settlement payments have equaled about 14 cents per pound they shipped to Closed Loop.

To calculate Sony’s payment amount, the parties looked at Sony’s market share, rather than estimates of pounds shipped. In court documents, the attorney for Sony and the landlords explained why.

In a motion to approve the deal, the plaintiffs argue the OEMs are legally responsible for cleanup partly because of their participation in state extended producer responsibility (EPR) laws, which obligate OEMs to help fund e-scrap collection and recycling if they want to sell their products in that state. Each OEM’s obligation is generally based on their market share.

“Consideration of an OEM’s market share therefore aligns with Plaintiffs’ theory of liability, which rests in part on the allegation that OEMs exert market power and influence by virtue of state EPR laws,” according to a declaration submitted by Sony’s attorney, Scott Furman.

In written declarations, Furman and Karl Heisler, attorney for Garrison Southfield Park, also explained that it would be “exceedingly difficult to ascribe specific weights of e-waste at the Facility to specific OEMs with any reasonable degree of certainty.” In many cases, OEMs contract with a company to ship e-scrap to one location, where disassembly takes place. Then, residuals, such as CRT glass, are transported by other parties to other locations.

“The bill of lading for any given load of E-Waste transported to the Facility, for example, does not identify whether any OEM claimed EPR credit for all or a part of that shipment, making it difficult to attribute individual shipments of E-Waste to any particular OEM,” the declarations both state.

Further complicating any analysis is the fact that OEMs “buy” weight, not full loads, for purposes of meeting their obligations, the attorneys both noted. As a result, any particular load and its bill of lading can include a commingling of OEM-funded e-scrap with non-OEM-funded e-scrap.

Based on numbers presented in the settlement, Sony’s payment would be on par with most other settling parties’ payments. A $1.2 million payment to compensate for 5.5% of the stockpile (or about 8.8 million pounds of the estimated total 160 million pounds) comes out to nearly 14 cents a pound.

Manufacturers’ differing responses

Heisler’s declaration noted that Sony showed “commitment from the outset of settlement negotiations to participate in the funding of cleanup activities” and that it is still cooperating with the plaintiffs.

At least two other OEMs appear set to fight in court.

Round Rock, Texas-based Dell filed an answer to the lawsuit on Nov. 10, and Hilliard, Ohio-headquartered Micro Center filed its response on Oct. 27. Both companies cited a number of reasons why they believe they’re not legally responsible. They each pointed fingers at the landlords.

“Any costs or damages complained of by Plaintiff were due to its own failure as the owner of the property to exercise proper and prudent care, including but not limited to permitting Closed Loop to operate on its property without reasonable prudent controls or inspections,” according to Dell. “As between Dell and Plaintiff, Plaintiff was in a better position to control the actions of its tenant, Closed Loop, in this regard.
 

Tags: CRTsLegalManufacturers
TweetShare
Jared Paben

Jared Paben

Related Stories

Data centers and AI combine to create ITAD ‘growth engine’

Component shortages drive demand for data center hardware

byDavid Daoud
November 10, 2026

Google, Microsoft and Sims Lifecycle Services report longer equipment lifecycles and growing demand for refurbished components, while rising asset values...

Rhode Island bill would make brands pay for recycling

Midterms put e-scrap legislation in focus

byDavid Daoud
November 6, 2026

New legislative majorities in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin could affect state electronics recycling programs, while federal initiatives face a divided government.

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

byPaul Lane
November 4, 2026

The company announced the plant closure soon after becoming a standalone company, following its sale by Sabic to a German...

Researchers work on fluorine-free battery binder

Researchers work on fluorine-free battery binder

byPaul Lane
October 16, 2026

Study authors found their alternative binder performed like traditional options with lower cost, environmental impact.

Trade-in firm reports higher values for used phones

Device trade-ins increase amid newest iPhone release

byPaul Lane
October 7, 2026

Some in the second-hand marketplace won’t see the full impact until well after the Duo foldable phone releases later this...

GM launches recycled EV battery line

GM launches recycled EV battery line

byPaul Lane
October 5, 2026

The automaker’s partnership with Cirba Solutions is meant to keep critical minerals in use to meet growing EV demand.

Load More
Next Post

Facility Focus: PreZero

2026 Buyers’ Guide

Equipment, services and technology suppliers serving the recycling industry.

Browse the Guide

More Posts

Closeup of PP with a chasing arrows recycling symbol.

PureCycle, WM sign rare 3-year bales contract

November 16, 2026
PureCycle sees easing headwinds to R-PP adoption

PureCycle shifts focus, secures feedstock

November 5, 2026

Goodwill eyes EPR revenue, starting with waste audit

November 12, 2026
Artificial intelligence is altering the marketplace for ITAD providers in numerous ways. | Shutterstock

AI alters ITAD economics

November 3, 2026

Alphabet’s Materra wants recyclers to see molecules, not bottles

November 13, 2026
Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

November 12, 2026
The missing link in e-plastic recycling

The missing link in e-plastic recycling

October 28, 2026
NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

November 4, 2026
PET bottles for recycling

PET imports reshape US markets as demand grows

November 11, 2026
IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

November 12, 2026
Load More

About & Publications

About Us

Staff
Job Listings

Archive

Magazines

Work With Us

Advertise
Contact
Terms and Privacy

Newsletters

Get the latest recycling news and analysis delivered to your inbox every week. Stay ahead on industry trends, policy updates, and insights from programs, processors, and innovators.

Subscribe

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
  • Recycling
  • E-Scrap
  • Plastics
  • Policy Now
  • Conferences
    • E-Scrap Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Magazines – Old
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Archive
  • Job Listings
  • Staff
Subscribe
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.