Editor’s note: EPR will be explored at the Textile Recycling Summit, co-located with the Plastics Recycling Conference, March 1-3 in National Harbor, Maryland. Register now for the best rates!
Every Goodwill in California counts as a producer under the state’s textile extended producer responsibility (EPR) law.
The reason is new merchandise. Stores sell a small amount of it, sometimes less than 1% of sales, and that still pushes them over the law’s revenue threshold, said Alexia Bednarz, director of sustainability for Goodwill of Central and Northern Arizona and Goodwill San Francisco Bay.
“That’s something to keep an eye out for,” Bednarz told attendees at the Goodwill Sustainability Summit on Nov. 10.
Bednarz moderated a panel on EPR, reuse and workforce development with speakers from WRAP, American Circular Textiles (AMCIRC) and the National Stewardship Action Council (NSAC). The group walked through what California’s Responsible Textile Recovery Act of 2024 (SB 707) will and won’t do for the thrift sector, and what other states should learn before they copy it.
Where SB 707 stands
SB 707 is the first statewide textile EPR law in the US. Producers of covered apparel and textile articles pay per-item fees to a producer responsibility organization (PRO), which funds collection, repair, sorting, reuse and recycling.
CalRecycle approved Landbell USA as the PRO effective Feb. 27, 2026. Producers had to register by July 1.
The American Apparel & Footwear Association (AAFA) is challenging that selection in Sacramento County Superior Court, arguing Landbell USA does not meet the law’s requirements for a PRO. A judge denied AAFA’s request for a preliminary injunction, so Landbell USA continues to operate while the case proceeds. A hearing on the underlying challenge is set for March 12, 2027.
Regulations are due by 2028. The full program takes effect in 2030. CalRecycle can impose penalties of up to $10,000 per day, or up to $50,000 per day for intentional, knowing or reckless violations.
Bednarz framed the law as both a risk and an opening for Goodwill.
On the risk side, she said Goodwills will face new competition for donations and for durable goods once producer-funded collection scales up.
On the benefit side, she said the PRO and producers could see the value of infrastructure Goodwill already runs: collection, reuse and sortation.
“We’re already experts at reuse, recirculating items and recycling things,” Bednarz said. “I would argue nobody does it better.”
Global EPR for textiles
Sarah Morley, strategic engagement manager at WRAP, said more than 7,000 pieces of EPR-related legislation exist globally. What is new is how fast textiles is joining them.
As of May 2026, textile EPR legislation was published in California, France, Hungary, Kenya, Latvia and the Netherlands, Morley said. Voluntary programs operate in Australia and Colombia. Proposals are moving in Germany, Spain, Italy, Sweden, Chile and several U.S. states. Under the 2025 revision of the EU Waste Framework Directive, every member state must have a textile EPR scheme by April 2028.
Morley pointed to six findings from WRAP’s recent EPR report for producers and PROs:
- Fair competition and adequate funding. Clothing and footwear make up about 43% of global cross-border e-commerce purchases, Morley said. If foreign sellers fall outside the producer definition, domestic brands pay for everyone. In France, Amazon, Etsy and other platforms require foreign sellers to register with a PRO before they can sell.
- Simple compliance. France lets producers under a set annual unit count pay a flat fee with no data requirements.
- Reuse first, recycling at scale. “A T-shirt can’t be worn forever,” Morley said. Recycling capacity is still needed to keep textiles out of landfills and incinerators.
- Harmonization across jurisdictions.
- Efficient use of EPR funds, with fees that reward more sustainable products.
- Strong governance. PROs should be nonprofits, Morley said, citing problems in Germany after it allowed for-profit PROs.
She also noted France’s repair subsidy. The PRO pays part of the cost of repairs at more than 700 registered repair businesses, so fixing a pair of shoes no longer costs as much as buying new ones.
Fee structures
Rachel Kibbe, founder and CEO of AMCIRC and Circular Services Group, said eco-modulated fees are one of the most closely watched levers in SB 707. The problem: the law gives “very little indication” of how those fees will be set.
That is why AMCIRC is active in CalRecycle’s informal workshops and comment periods. Kibbe said California’s fee structure could reward durability, repairability and reusability first, then post-consumer recycled content, then post-industrial content.
Unlike California’s packaging EPR law, SB 54, SB 707 has no recycling targets, Kibbe said. Incentives for recycled content, particularly U.S.-collected and U.S.-processed material, are where her group is focusing.
“If these fees are not set in a way that supports new markets for what’s collected, we will just have a very expensive landfill,” Kibbe said.
She spoke about EPR’s limits. It funds free, convenient collection. It will not address trade law, fund national infrastructure or fix a patchwork of conflicting state bills. It also won’t deliver the industrial policy that sectors like renewables and EVs received, including tax credits, national funding or sales and use tax exemptions for secondhand goods.
Some fixes are federal only. Recycled finished goods have no unique Harmonized Tariff Schedule code, which Kibbe said creates problems at US Customs and Border Protection. And what counts as recycling is another fight. Kibbe said textiles will need advanced, non-mechanical recycling, which many environmental groups oppose in packaging EPR debates. AMCIRC supports the Recycled Materials Attribution Act (H.R. 7502), which advanced out of the House Energy and Commerce Committee in September.
Kibbe also pointed to the Government Accountability Office’s second textile report, released Oct. 16, which lays out federal and state policy options. EPR is just one of them.
A national EPR framework is not on the table. Kibbe said her group asked Congress early on for a single federal bill.
“They were like, ‘Absolutely not,'” she said. Lawmakers told her there was too much “scar tissue” from packaging and that they would let the states fight it out first.
Instead, Kibbe said, the federal conversation is shifting toward manufacturing and reshoring, and toward adding textiles to funding programs that currently leave the sector out.
Lessons from California
Heidi Sanborn, CEO and executive director of NSAC and one of the original co-directors behind SB 707, urged other states not to rush.
“If you copy it now, you may copy mistakes,” Sanborn said.
She pointed to California’s mattress stewardship law as a cautionary tale. A government audit found 14 major flaws, she said, including visible consumer fees being used to sue the state over oversight and rules. A cleanup bill followed shortly after. California’s carpet stewardship law initially had no required stakeholder input, which led to another cleanup bill mandating a state-picked advisory board.
Sanborn now sits on Landbell USA’s advisory board.
Gaps remain. Area rugs are covered by neither California’s carpet law nor SB 707.
“We’re kind of in no man’s land there,” she said.
She said states should watch who is fighting the law, referring to the challenge to the PRO selection. “I’ve never even seen that before,” Sanborn said. Responsible end market standards for textiles, including when exports are acceptable, are also unsettled.
Sanborn praised Washington’s approach. She said Rep. Kristine Reeves plans to introduce a readiness assessment bill that would have producers map existing infrastructure before the state commits to a full program. Reeves’ earlier textile EPR bill, HB 1420, stalled in the 2026 session.
Kibbe noted New York lawmakers have also introduced textile EPR legislation, including A 6193 and S 8502. Minnesota introduced a bill last session that would cover all textiles, including mattresses and carpet. Massachusetts already bans textiles from disposal, and Rhode Island is launching a statewide public education program in 2026.
Public education will fall to Goodwills on the front line, Sanborn said, and producers are on the hook to fund and support it.
Her advice to Goodwill leaders: get every legislator who represents you into your facilities before a bill shows up.
“If you’re not at the table, you’re on the menu,” Sanborn said.






















