Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion

    E-scrap feedstock competition mixed amid investments

    Open pit copper mine in Arizona.

    Trump touts aggressive US critical mineral goals

    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion

    E-scrap feedstock competition mixed amid investments

    Open pit copper mine in Arizona.

    Trump touts aggressive US critical mineral goals

    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
No Result
View All Result
Home Analysis Opinion

In My Opinion: BAN’s tracking project missed opportunities to advance industry

bySteven Elmore, CyclePoint at SourceAmerica.
November 9, 2016
in Opinion
Shipping

Basel Action Network’s e-Trash Transparency report had the potential to produce positive results and spur constructive changes within electronics recycling, but instead it risks alienating large sections of the global industry.

We all need strong, vocal advocates for proper handling and disposition of electronics, worldwide. Just as a person wanting to live waste-free encourages those around them to minimize their own environmental impact, BAN has widened the bell curve of responsibility, to the benefit of our entire industry.

Faulty research methodology

The flaw within the group’s series of reports is the misapplication of the scientific method for evaluating results and subsequent manner in which results are presented and used. Without a clearly defined presentation on the study’s structure, we don’t know if the material has been appropriately handled throughout its industry journey – how often did the GPS units register, were they deployed simultaneously, how often were they checked, how long did the time study run, were participants selected at random? Any one of those factors could invalidate a significant portion of the study results.

Merely impregnating devices with foreign objects does not provide detailed information about end-of-life disposition, nor does it result in reliable scientific evidence concerning the journey devices take though the industry.

For example, consider a known working printer impregnated and moved responsibly to a certified end-of-life option, only then to be discovered to have issues related to a GPS device. Multiple handlers could touch this device, in compliance with multiple certification standards, only for it to arrive at a certified shred location and potentially cause a quality, environmental, health and safety (QEH&S) violation if the GPS is not removed or discovered prior to being shredded. The very real threat to worker safety through this process should have been addressed by a cross-functional industry working group representing multiple certification standards prior to implementation.

To be blunt: If BAN thought a recycler was a concern, then that recycler received one or more impregnated devices, rendering the study incapable of producing results other than that which was desired to promote BAN or substantiate a hypothesis about the handling of electronic devices. Not releasing the report’s full data and evolution of all impregnated devices for industry evaluation through a cooperative arrangement between leading certification standards has led many in the industry to question the validity of the results and subsequent interpretation of the facts.

The facts of the study should have been used to reach a conclusion that advances the entire industry, not simply the promotion of BAN’s e-Stewards certification. We have been presented with incomplete information designed to support one certification and simultaneously push for the exclusion of export as a reliable option for the economic, sustainable and socially responsible method for the handling of electronic scrap.

Exports are essential, not evil

Another important aspect of this discussion is the fact the BAN report is being used to say the export handling of any product is irresponsible, but that is an irresponsible statement. Where would the U.S. be without export commerce? Imagine the Great Salt Lake covered in electronics nine feet deep each year. That is the volume of material we are talking about and that volume is growing annually. Export is vital to our industry.

We would all like to see investment in domestic capability and handling; however, how realistic is that in the near term? With many factors at play like the cost of equipment, labor, legal and public support, how long could our industry sustain this type of model before the introduction of federal regulatory involvement?

This report should be used to expand or improve our global handling of electronic material. BAN’s stance concerning the non-export of electronics is unfeasible, given our nation’s need for domestic and international processing. The solution isn’t to stop all export; the solution is to work together as an industry to develop solutions and capacity for handling all viable goods produced, through reuse, right to repair, domestic and international reclamation on a global scale.

In summary, BAN’s e-Trash Transparency reports are neither objective nor transparent and, sadly, appear to be a self-promoting ploy for self-gain. I am disappointed that BAN, a recognized resource for change and awareness in our industry, was unwilling to equal the same standard of transparency it requires of others.

Attacking the efforts and achievements of those who paved the way for the electronics recycling industry with the same vigor reserved for the few unscrupulous operators, when the number of compliant operators continues its meteoric rise, is to historically negate the positive intent by which most organizations conduct themselves.

Frankly, I think our industry expects and deserves better.

Steven Elmore is the senior program manager for CyclePoint at SourceAmerica He can be contacted at selmore@cyclepointus.org.

The views and opinions expressed are those of the author and do not imply endorsement by Resource Recycling, Inc. If you have a subject you wish to cover in a future Op-Ed, please send a short proposal to news@resource-recycling.com for consideration.

Tags: Trade & Tariffs
TweetShare
Steven Elmore, CyclePoint at SourceAmerica.

Steven Elmore, CyclePoint at SourceAmerica.

Related Stories

RecyClass hits 500 EU recyclability evals

EU PET import codes set to begin

byAntoinette Smith
November 18, 2026

The new codes for PET flake will take effect in January, but the global impact remains to be seen, according...

Dow bullish on PE pricing into 2027

Dow bullish on PE pricing into 2027

byAntoinette Smith
October 23, 2026

Executives cited elevated feedstock costs, lower inventories and constrained production resulting from the US war in Iran as support for...

APR, PROs appeal to Ottawa for help

APR, PROs appeal to Ottawa for help

byAntoinette Smith
October 6, 2026

APR and Circular Materials say policy goals risk failure without government actions that acknowledge market realities.

Analysis: Undersupply of PCR is ‘stifling’ brand goals

US lawmakers urge protection of domestic RPET

byAntoinette Smith
September 25, 2026

In a letter to the US Trade Representative, five representatives asked the USTR to consider trade remedies and support verification...

Canada tariffs latest in new normal for RPET

Canada tariffs latest in new normal for RPET

byAntoinette Smith
September 11, 2026

Tensions with the valuable trading partner have frayed nerves for over a year, but North American markets already have tariff...

Bags of collected agricultural twine for Cleanfarms twine recycling contest

News in Brief: August 10, 2026

byIsabella Burke
August 10, 2026

An Alberta twine recycling contest, Pellitteri expands waste and recycling services into the Milwaukee area and the Canadian government awards...

Load More
Next Post

Safety, recycling and OSHA: Can they all get along?

2026 Buyers’ Guide

Equipment, services and technology suppliers serving the recycling industry.

Browse the Guide

More Posts

Closeup of PP with a chasing arrows recycling symbol.

PureCycle, WM sign rare 3-year bales contract

November 16, 2026

Goodwill eyes EPR revenue, starting with waste audit

November 12, 2026

Alphabet’s Materra wants recyclers to see molecules, not bottles

November 13, 2026
Artificial intelligence is altering the marketplace for ITAD providers in numerous ways. | Shutterstock

AI alters ITAD economics

November 3, 2026
PureCycle sees easing headwinds to R-PP adoption

PureCycle shifts focus, secures feedstock

November 5, 2026
The missing link in e-plastic recycling

The missing link in e-plastic recycling

October 28, 2026
NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

November 4, 2026
Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

November 12, 2026
Adam Gendell

PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

November 16, 2026
Vessel gives excess inventory a second life

Vessel gives excess inventory a second life

November 13, 2026
Load More

About & Publications

About Us

Staff
Job Listings

Archive

Magazines

Work With Us

Advertise
Contact
Terms and Privacy

Newsletters

Get the latest recycling news and analysis delivered to your inbox every week. Stay ahead on industry trends, policy updates, and insights from programs, processors, and innovators.

Subscribe

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
  • Recycling
  • E-Scrap
  • Plastics
  • Policy Now
  • Conferences
    • E-Scrap Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Magazines – Old
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Archive
  • Job Listings
  • Staff
Subscribe
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.