Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion
    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    A five star ranking with one under a microscope

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 9

    Data centers and AI combine to create ITAD ‘growth engine’

    Component shortages drive demand for data center hardware

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion
    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    A five star ranking with one under a microscope

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 9

    Data centers and AI combine to create ITAD ‘growth engine’

    Component shortages drive demand for data center hardware

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
No Result
View All Result
Home Recycling

Study: Recyclable packaging not always greenest option

Dan LeifbyDan Leif
December 11, 2018
in Recycling

Oregon’s environmental agency has released research that suggests several popular packaging attributes – including “recyclable” and “recycled content” – do not consistently result in lower-impact products.

The 106-page report from the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) was finalized this summer but is just now being publicized.

It continues Oregon DEQ’s efforts to frame decision-making in the context of sustainable materials management (SMM), a concept that has gained traction among a variety of public and private stakeholders. In SMM frameworks, complete material life cycles are taken into account when designing programs and policy.

As SMM strategies have advanced, there has been growing discussion over where the recycling industry fits in. Businesses, the U.S. EPA and others have held up isolated examples showing packaging materials that are widely recyclable or use recycled content don’t always emerge as the most environmentally friendly options when evaluated via life cycle assessment.

“We got to wondering if these types of examples were the exception, or whether perhaps popular [recycling-related] attributes might not reliably correlate with low-impact choices,” said Minal Mistry, who led the research effort for DEQ.

Mistry’s comments came in a statement on the research that DEQ prepared for Resource Recycling.

‘Design and material selection is more important’

In undertaking the recent research, Oregon officials sought to gather a significantly larger data set around the question of whether recyclability and use of recycled content should always be the goal in construction of packaging and foodservice products.

DEQ hired a contractor, Franklin Associates, and that company combed through publicly available life-cycle assessments (LCAs) published worldwide between 2000 and 2017. The analysis found hundreds of comparisons between packaging and foodservice items with the attributes of interest and comparable items without those same attributes.

Minal Mistry, Oregon DEQ
Minal Mistry of the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality.

According to DEQ, the results were mixed.

For example, increasing the recycled content of plastics was found to almost always lessen the product or packaging’s environmental footprint in a variety of ways. “Once you’ve chosen to use a specific material – say, PET – increasing the recycled content of that material is typically a good choice,” said Mistry.

But when the researchers looked at the numbers from over 530 environmental-impact comparisons found in the literature between different materials (for example, a steel can versus an aseptic carton), higher recycled content was found to have no consistent correlation with lower impacts. In fact, the DEQ report indicates that in 61 percent of all comparisons, the packaging material with higher recycled content actually correlated with significantly higher (worse) environmental impacts.

Turning to recyclability, results of over 520 comparisons were basically a wash: 44 percent of comparisons found significantly higher environmental impacts for recyclable packages while 39 percent of comparisons found significantly lower (beneficial) impacts.

“While recycling is beneficial, design and material selection is more critical,” Mistry noted. “The [recycling-related] attributes by themselves are too broad to be helpful in isolation, and need to be used with care.”

Similarly mixed results were found when researchers analyzed packaging and products labeled “bio-based” or “compostable.”

Wider debate within industry

The study results come out as a variety of different industry stakeholders are more actively voicing their perspectives on the shift toward life-cycle-based decision-making when it comes to materials use.

For instance, some observers have noted that LCAs fail to account for the impacts associated with items that are mismanaged at end of life, a concern of growing importance as the marine plastics problem grabs more attention. In a follow-up email, Oregon DEQ said it acknowledges such limitations of LCAs, but the government agency also pointed out that the recycling attributes in question themselves have only a limited relationship to reducing marine debris from the U.S.

On another front, recycling groups have begun expressing anxieties that the growing drumbeat around SMM could push brand owners and others away from recycling commitments and behaviors that have taken years to solidify.

The DEQ said in the statement to Resource Recycling that the study results are not a critique of recycling itself.

“Recycling – the act of making products from formerly used materials – has been evaluated extensively for its environmental impacts and is typically found to be beneficial,” said David Allaway, a senior policy analyst at Oregon DEQ who also contributed to the recent research. “But recycling and recyclability, while related concepts, are fundamentally different. Recycling describes a preferable method for managing discarded materials, while recyclability simply describes the technical and economic potential of a material to be recycled. As this research shows, just because a material is ‘recyclable’ does not guarantee that it is consistently the lower impact choice.”

Photo credit: Trong Nguyen/Shutterstock
 

Tags: DataHard-to-Recycle MaterialsPlasticsResearch
TweetShare
Dan Leif

Dan Leif

Dan Leif is the managing editor at Resource Recycling, Inc., which publishes Resource Recycling, Plastics Recycling Update and E-Scrap News. He has been with the company since 2013 and has edited different trade publications since 2006. He can be contacted at dan@resource-recycling.com.

Related Stories

California expansion gives Solar Panel Recycling national reach

California expansion gives Solar Panel Recycling national reach

byPaul Lane
November 16, 2026

The company continues to build its capacity in anticipation of a coming surge of panel decommissioning.

PET bottles for recycling

PET imports reshape US markets as demand grows

byAntoinette Smith
November 11, 2026

New NAPCOR data shows record RPET use in bottles even as US bottle recycling continues to fall.

Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

byKatie Kinnear, director of brand strategy, Routeware
November 11, 2026

A collection truck is the only part of the system that meets the household where contamination behavior happens, again and...

EPR at work: Sask adds foam densifier

EPR at work: Sask adds foam densifier

byAntoinette Smith
October 29, 2026

Transporting rigid packaging foams is challenging due to being lightweight and bulky, but the new densifier compacts the material at...

Hitachi Energy partner turns spools into PVC pipe feed

Hitachi Energy partner turns spools into PVC pipe feed

byAntoinette Smith
October 22, 2026

A grant-funded granulator at J. Carter Enterprises has recovered about 250,000 pounds of plastic from Hitachi Energy’s oversized wire spools...

Triton to make rail ties from artificial turf

Triton to make rail ties from artificial turf

byAntoinette Smith
October 20, 2026

The Missouri-based company is adding capacity to recover HDPE from retired TenCate turf, providing demand for the hard-to-recycle material.

Load More
Next Post

How a materials recovery facility will sort flexible plastics

2026 Buyers’ Guide

Equipment, services and technology suppliers serving the recycling industry.

Browse the Guide

More Posts

PureCycle sees easing headwinds to R-PP adoption

PureCycle shifts focus, secures feedstock

November 5, 2026
PET bottles for recycling

PET imports reshape US markets as demand grows

November 11, 2026
Closeup of PP with a chasing arrows recycling symbol.

PureCycle, WM sign rare 3-year bales contract

November 16, 2026
Artificial intelligence is altering the marketplace for ITAD providers in numerous ways. | Shutterstock

AI alters ITAD economics

November 3, 2026
NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

November 4, 2026

Goodwill eyes EPR revenue, starting with waste audit

November 12, 2026
The missing link in e-plastic recycling

The missing link in e-plastic recycling

October 28, 2026
Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

November 12, 2026
Textile EPR needs end markets, not just collection

Textile EPR needs end markets, not just collection

November 10, 2026

Alphabet’s Materra wants recyclers to see molecules, not bottles

November 13, 2026
Load More

About & Publications

About Us

Staff
Job Listings

Archive

Magazines

Work With Us

Advertise
Contact
Terms and Privacy

Newsletters

Get the latest recycling news and analysis delivered to your inbox every week. Stay ahead on industry trends, policy updates, and insights from programs, processors, and innovators.

Subscribe

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
  • Recycling
  • E-Scrap
  • Plastics
  • Policy Now
  • Conferences
    • E-Scrap Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Magazines – Old
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Archive
  • Job Listings
  • Staff
Subscribe
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.