Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion
    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    A five star ranking with one under a microscope

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 9

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
    • All
    • Certification Scorecard
    • Industry Announcements
    • Opinion
    From claims to custody: PCR procurement grows up

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 16

    Adam Gendell

    PET producers ride ‘local for local’ wave

    May pricing bullish for most bales

    HDPE resists seasonal, economic forces

    IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

    Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    Recycling tracking data is already on your truck

    A five star ranking with one under a microscope

    Certification scorecard — week of Nov. 9

  • Conferences
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • E-Scrap: The Longevity Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Publications
    • E-Scrap News
    • Plastics Recycling Update
    • Policy Now
    • Resource Recycling
    • Other Topics
      • All Topics
      • Brand Owners
      • Critical Minerals
      • Glass
      • Grant Watch / RFPs
      • Markets
      • Organics
      • Packaging
      • Research
      • Technology
      • Textiles
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Resource Recycling
No Result
View All Result
Home Policy Now

Oregon’s EPR law survives first constitutional test

Stefanie ValenticbyStefanie Valentic
August 28, 2026
in Policy Now, Recycling
Minnesota EPR program advances in budget bill

rawf8/shutterstock

A federal judge has ruled that Oregon’s Recycling Modernization Act (RMA) is constitutional, delivering the first full-record decision testing an extended producer responsibility (EPR) law against the US Constitution.

The case has been shadowing the state’s EPR rollout for more than a year.

US District Judge Michael H. Simon issued a 71-page decision on Aug. 27, concluding that the law, enacted as Senate Bill 582 in 2021, does not violate either the dormant Commerce Clause or the Due Process Clause.

The ruling comes in the case of National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors v. Feldon, filed by NAW in July 2025 and tried before Simon over five days in Portland this July.

Simon leaned on Justice Louis Brandeis’s “laboratories of democracy” framework to explain the court’s deference to Oregon’s approach, writing that it is “one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous State may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory, and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country.”

He traced the RMA’s lineage to Oregon’s 1971 Bottle Bill, calling it a continuation of the state’s “innovative leadership” on waste policy.

The decision runs through NAW’s arguments one by one, rejecting each:

Small-producer exemption: NAW argued the RMA’s carve-out for government bodies and small businesses under $5 million in gross revenue facially discriminates against interstate commerce.

Simon found NAW lacked standing to challenge the governmental exemption. On the revenue-based carve-out, that NAW offered only hypotheticals, no trial evidence that the exemption actually shifts market share toward in-state businesses.

Excessive fees: NAW pointed to Circular Action Alliance’s 2025 Annual Report, which showed CAA collected $145.5 million but spent only $56.5 million.

Simon called that a reserve-building pattern typical of a program in “its second year,” not a constitutional violation.

Pike balancing: NAW’s experts didn’t quantify the RMA’s interstate effects specifically enough to clear the threshold showing a “substantial or significant burden on interstate commerce.” Pike balancing is a legal test, from Pike v. Bruce Church (1970), that weighs a law’s burden on interstate commerce against its local benefits, striking the law down only if that burden is “clearly excessive” in comparison.

Private delegation to CAA: NAW argued Oregon handed unconstitutional authority to a “self-interested” private entity.

Simon held that producers aren’t actually compelled to join CAA. They can form a competing PRO or use the RMA’s private-recycling exemption. So, CAA’s confidential fee-setting methodology and arbitration provisions don’t trigger a due-process claim.

DEQ’s civil-penalty process: Simon found the on due-process issue is adequately protected by notice-and-cure periods, a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge and court appeal rights, with no penalty due until appeals are exhausted.

The ruling is the latest turn in a case Policy Now has tracked from the start. The court dismissed several of NAW’s claims and granted a narrower preliminary injunction back in February, then  denied four trade groups’ bids to join the suit that April, around the same time DEQ issued its first list of noncompliant producers under the law.

“While NAW supports the goals of a circular economy, we believe Oregon’s law is unconstitutional and structured in a way that undermines, rather than advances, those goals,” Brian Wild, the association’s chief government affairs officer, said in a statement after July’s trial concluded.

Wild argued the trial “exposed a fundamental accountability problem with EPR,” pointing to CAA’s “confidential methodology producers cannot review or verify.”

An appeal to the Ninth Circuit is possible given CAA also administers PRO programs in California, Colorado, Maryland and Minnesota. The NAW has filed suit against EPR laws in both Colorado and California.

NAW’s other EPR fights

With the issue of EPR’s constitutionality, NAW is arguing similar claims at three of the seven state packaging EPR programs administered by CAA:

  • California: NAW joined a 17-state coalition led by Nebraska Attorney General Mike Hilgers in Nebraska v. Heller (E.D. Cal.), filed June 22 as the sole business plaintiff alongside Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Utah and West Virginia. The suit challenges SB 54’s regulations, which took permanent effect May 1, on Commerce Clause, Import-Export Clause, First Amendment and private-delegation grounds — naming CAA itself as a defendant this time, not just the state regulator. It’s separate from a narrower environmental-groups challenge to SB 54’s regulations (NRDC, Californians Against Waste, Oceana) that predates the NAW suit and doesn’t involve CAA.
  • Colorado: NAW moved Aug. 5 for a preliminary injunction against Colorado’s Producer Responsibility Program for Statewide Recycling Act, seeking to bar enforcement and defer member fee obligations on an expedited basis. Colorado’s response is due Sept. 16. It’s NAW’s third state EPR suit and follows a separate, earlier state-court challenge from the Independent Lubricant Manufacturers Association.
Tags: EPRLegislation & EnforcementPackagingPolicy Now
TweetShare
Stefanie Valentic

Stefanie Valentic

Stefanie Valentic is an award-winning journalist who has covered the waste and recycling industry for more than five years. Throughout her career, she has led editorial teams and served as a keynote speaker, moderator and panelist at numerous trade shows and conferences.

Related Stories

State recycling cuts reversed in N.C. House budget

North Carolina nears battery disposal ban

byDavid Daoud
November 17, 2026

North Carolina will ban the disposal of lithium-ion batteries in landfills and most permitted incinerators starting Dec. 1. The deadline...

Goodwill eyes EPR revenue, starting with waste audit

byStefanie Valentic
November 12, 2026

Goodwill sustainability leaders say the nonprofit’s donation network could serve packaging and textile EPR programs, but they first need hard...

IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

byDavid Daoud
November 12, 2026

Developers and decommissioning firms face uncertainty amid communities’ concerns over the impact centers create.

Produce packers face narrow exits under SB 54

byStefanie Valentic
November 11, 2026

Fiber, compostables, PCR and monomaterial films all come with tradeoffs for fresh produce, and no single swap will work across...

Textile EPR needs end markets, not just collection

Textile EPR needs end markets, not just collection

byStefanie Valentic
November 10, 2026

Reju CEO Patrik Frisk said textile EPR programs will fall short unless they also create demand for recycled material.

Inside the Circle: Will we lose our shirts over CA textile EPR?

Inside the Circle: Will we lose our shirts over CA textile EPR?

byBill Shireman
November 9, 2026

Some advocates have worked to block chemical recycling under the packaging law, but their strategy is going to backfire.

Load More
Next Post
EFS-plastics invests as EPR takes shape

EFS-plastics invests as EPR takes shape

2026 Buyers’ Guide

Equipment, services and technology suppliers serving the recycling industry.

Browse the Guide

More Posts

Closeup of PP with a chasing arrows recycling symbol.

PureCycle, WM sign rare 3-year bales contract

November 16, 2026
PureCycle sees easing headwinds to R-PP adoption

PureCycle shifts focus, secures feedstock

November 5, 2026

Goodwill eyes EPR revenue, starting with waste audit

November 12, 2026
Artificial intelligence is altering the marketplace for ITAD providers in numerous ways. | Shutterstock

AI alters ITAD economics

November 3, 2026

Alphabet’s Materra wants recyclers to see molecules, not bottles

November 13, 2026
Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

Modern Mining raises $40 million in IPO

November 12, 2026
The missing link in e-plastic recycling

The missing link in e-plastic recycling

October 28, 2026
NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

NexPoint Materials to shutter Alabama plastics plant

November 4, 2026
PET bottles for recycling

PET imports reshape US markets as demand grows

November 11, 2026
IT asset disposition and electronics recycling: Now and then

Data center moratoriums cast development shadow

November 12, 2026
Load More

About & Publications

About Us

Staff
Job Listings

Archive

Magazines

Work With Us

Advertise
Contact
Terms and Privacy

Newsletters

Get the latest recycling news and analysis delivered to your inbox every week. Stay ahead on industry trends, policy updates, and insights from programs, processors, and innovators.

Subscribe

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • The Latest
  • Podcast
  • Analysis
  • Recycling
  • E-Scrap
  • Plastics
  • Policy Now
  • Conferences
    • E-Scrap Conference
    • Plastics Recycling Conference
    • Resource Recycling Conference
    • Textiles Recovery Summit
  • Magazines – Old
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Archive
  • Job Listings
  • Staff
Subscribe
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.