The consumer electronics industry wants states to stop setting collection targets in electronics EPR laws. Instead, manufacturers would fund free, convenient collection, including payments to the local governments that run drop-off sites.
Katie Reilly, vice president of environmental affairs and industry sustainability at the Consumer Technology Association (CTA), laid out the trade group’s updated EPR policy principles at an Electronics Recycling Coordination Clearinghouse (ERCC) workshop during the E-Scrap Conference on Oct. 26. CTA adopted the principles at the end of 2025.
Reilly said CTA is in active negotiations with a couple of states and hopes the talks produce bills in the 2027 legislative sessions.
Jason Linnell, executive director of the National Center for Electronics Recycling (NCER), which co-runs ERCC, called the presentation a significant development. Manufacturers have not had a unified set of industry principles in the past, he said.
Twenty-five states and Washington DC have electronics recycling laws, covering about two-thirds of the US population. No new law has passed since DC’s law in 2014. The programs have collected more than 10 billion pounds of electronics.
The laws vary widely in which products they cover, who can use them and how manufacturers pay. Reilly said cathode-ray tubes are the only product every program covers, and households are the only collection source every program shares.
The laws were also crafted to combat a different issue. Twenty years ago it was CRT glass, Reilly said. Today it is battery-embedded devices and products that didn’t exist when the laws passed.
What CTA wants
The principles call for:
- Convenience over targets. Programs should guarantee free, convenient collection for households rather than chase weight targets Reilly called arbitrary. Products can take five to 15 years to reach the end of life, and devices keep getting lighter, she said.
- Every eligible producer pays. If a manufacturer’s product can be collected and recycled under a program, that manufacturer should fund it. Reilly pointed to Wisconsin, where a small group of manufacturers pays for a much wider range of eligible products.
- Competition under a coordinating body. Manufacturers would choose their own service providers but work under a clearinghouse that ensures statewide goals are met.
- Fair compensation for local governments. Reilly called local programs the backbone of electronics collection.
- Public education. In CTA’s latest recycling and reuse survey, 27% of respondents said they threw away a tech device in the past 12 months. Of those, 31% said they didn’t know the device could be recycled.
- An on-ramp for new products. A stakeholder process would decide whether new devices belong in an electronics program, a separate program or none at all.
- Collector and recycler standards.
Reilly said CTA’s preferred structure is a hybrid of the Oregon and Illinois models. Illinois uses a clearinghouse with five or six plans operating underneath it. Oregon’s new convenience standard requires 95% of residents to live within 15 miles of a collection site.
A single manufacturer plan probably cannot deliver the roughly 200 sites Oregon requires, Reilly said. That is why CTA wants a coordinating body over competing plans.
She pointed attendees to a Minnesota bill, HF 4997, as an example of where the industry stands. Article 1 covers removable batteries and follows model legislation from PRBA – The Rechargeable Battery Association. Article 2 would overhaul Minnesota’s electronics program along CTA’s lines.
The bill did not pass. Reilly said it is “a good marker” but not model legislation, and CTA may revisit parts of it.
Paying local collectors
Asked how fair compensation would work, Reilly said it means covering Gaylord boxes, pallets and labor. Payments could be tiered, she said, because some collectors fill semitrailers and others cannot.
Oregon already requires it. The approved PRO there must submit its compensation plan to the state, though the details were redacted as confidential, Reilly said.
Cost is driving the industry’s interest in competition. Reilly said some CTA members will pay more to fund packaging EPR in a state than electronics EPR.
“That’s crazy to a certain extent,” she said. Those costs reach consumers eventually.
She also drew a line between electronics and other EPR programs.
“Electronics doesn’t need to look like packaging. It doesn’t need to look like batteries,” Reilly said.























