US fiber exports rebound after two years of declines

Scrap fiber exports to China collapsed in 2021, but the rest of the world more than made up the difference. Scrap plastics, however, continued their years-long decline in shipments.

The U.S. Census Bureau recently released trade data for the fourth quarter of 2021, allowing Resource Recycling to calculate full-year 2021 numbers and compare them with prior years.

The data shows that U.S. companies exported 17.97 million short tons of recovered fiber (including both papers and cardboard) in 2021, up from 15.95 million short tons from the prior year, or up 13%. The upward move marked a reversal of two years of declines, which had been precipitated by China’s National Sword campaign. 

Plastics, however, continued the declines they’ve experienced since National Sword began curtailing Chinese imports of certain materials starting in 2018. The U.S. exported 1.21 billion pounds of scrap plastics in 2021, down from 1.38 billion pounds the year before, or down about 12%. 

Paper and cardboard shipments increase

The following shows total U.S. scrap fiber exports over the past five years (story continues below chart):

Last year brought huge swings in weights shipped to the top 10 destinations for U.S. scrap fiber. More material went to Thailand (up 203%), Malaysia (up 109%), India (up 89%), Mexico (up 66%), Vietnam (up 48%), Taiwan (up 26%), Indonesia (up 11%) and Canada (up 7%). All other countries combined took in 45% more scrap fiber.

They were all largely making up from a collapse in shipments to China, which took in 89% less. Specifically, China imported 548,000 short tons of U.S. scrap fiber in 2021, down from 4.97 million the year before. Finally, shipments to South Korea declined by 3%.

The following chart shows the top 10 recipients (plus all other combined) in 2021, compared with their numbers the year before (story continues below chart):

Plastic exports continue to fall

The downward move in scrap plastic shipments last year continues a years-long decline. In 2017, the year China’s National Sword campaign was first announced but had not yet gone into full effect, the U.S. exported 3.68 billion pounds.

The following shows total U.S. scrap plastic exports over the past five years (story continues below chart):

As was the case with fiber, 2021 brought wild swings in weights shipped to different countries. Those countries receiving considerably more of the U.S.’s scrap plastic included India (up 110%), El Salvador (up 77%), Mexico (up 34%), Indonesia (up 27%) and Canada (up 2%).

Others dramatically slashed the amount they brought in from the U.S. Those included Hong Kong (down 72%), Taiwan (down 56%), Malaysia (down 32%), Vietnam (down 31%) and Turkey (down 24%). All other countries not in the 2021 top 10 combined were down 35%.

The following chart shows the top 10 recipients (plus all other combined) in 2021, compared with their numbers the year before (story continues below chart):

Canada remains, by far, the largest destination for scrap plastic bales. The U.S.’s neighbor to the north jumped into the No. 1 spot starting in 2019, following Malaysia’s National Sword-inspired crackdown on imports.

Starting in 2021, an amendment to the The Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal went into effect. The amendment intended to further regulate the global trade in plastics, banning shipments of certain types of material. The U.S. and Canada negotiated an agreement that continued allowing the countries to trade without the additional Basel controls, however.

Since the Basel Convention amendment went into effect, environmental justice activists have pressured shipping lines to stop accepting cargo that consists of plastic waste. The latest line to announce a halt to the practice was CMA CGM Group, the third-largest ocean freight line in the world.

More stories about exports

• Threatened tariffs could have indirect effect on recycled fiber
• Fiber exports slip in third quarter, plastics flat from 2023
• Sizable drop in fiber exports, plastics remain flat